The Third Beis HaMikdash: Man-made or God Given?

Speaker:
Ask speaker
Date:
July 08 2020
Length:
28min 37s
Downloads:
49
Views:
1439
Comments:
3

Series: Contemporary Halacha

Venue: BRS Afternoon Kollel BRS Afternoon Kollel

Halacha:
Beit Hamikdash 

    More from this:
    Comments
    3 comments     Leave a Comment
    Title:
    Comment:
    Anonymous: 
    1. Title: BEIT HAMIKDASH
      Author: ABBA HOROVITZ
      Reply
      Shalom, I listened to your podcast on Binyan hamikdash and feel that you presented a very one sided understanding of Rashi . Great Rabbis in our generation have unfortunately used this Rashi to deflect all responsibility of binyan hamikdash and have thrown the entire enterprise onto God. Instead of questioning this Rashi and determining whether this is shitas Rashi in the rest of Shas and Torah, they flippantly embrace this problematic Rashi and actually use it to posek halacha. This is patently wrong and is מוציא לעז on Rashi. According to the 9th עיקר אמונה of the Rambam, mitzvot never change. This idea of Hashem doing our mitzvot goes against the principles of faith. More importantly, Rashi in at least 5 other places says explicitly man will build the Mikdash וְיִשְׁמְרוּ אֶת כָּל צוּרָתוֹ - רש'י --ילמדו עניני מידות מפיך שידעו לעשותם לעת קץ. יחזקאל מג יא. All Rishonim and Achronim say man must build the mikdash. I can send you the list. No achron takes this Rashi to heart. In fact, according to כללי הש'ס , Rashi is only a parshan and not a posek. see יד מלאכי and see בית יוסף אורח חיים סימן י ולענין הלכה נראה דאע"ג דהרא"ש מפרש כפירוש רש"י כיון דרש"י מפרש הוא ולא פסקן הוו להו הרמב"ם והרא"ש ז"ל חד לגבי חד והלכה כהרמב"ם ז"לד דמסתבר טעמיה דבנתכוין לאוסופי פסול ובנתכוין לבטולי כשר ועוד שדברי רב פפא מיפרשי שפיר טפי אליביה ממאי דמיפרשי אליביה דרש"י: Most importantly, the mikdash is not just one mitzvah but a trigger for over 200 mitzvot that can only be done on har habayit. How can one based on acryptic Rashi uproot 1/3 of the Torah when we have a klal of תורה לאו בשמים היא. WE MUST DO ALL MITZVOT. I live in Israel and go up to Har habyit. I have learned Kodshim for over 15 years and have investigated this topic thorougly. I actually graduated YU in 88. You are clearly a talmid chacham and you give a great shiur . I mean no disrespect, but feel these issues are often treated very שטחי and require a more in-depth understanding. The number one question that must be answered with regard to this Rashi is: can Hashem do our mitzvot for us and if so, when did Hashem change his Torah and mitzvot that he gave on Har sinai? תורה היא וללמוד אני צריך. ABBA HOROVITZ
    2. Title: BEIT HAMIKDASH
      Author: ABBA HOROVITZ
      Reply
      Shalom, I listened to your podcast on Binyan hamikdash and feel that you presented a very one sided understanding of Rashi . Great Rabbis in our generation have unfortunately used this Rashi to deflect all responsibility of binyan hamikdash and have thrown the entire enterprise onto God. Instead of questioning this Rashi and determining whether this is shitas Rashi in the rest of Shas and Torah, they flippantly embrace this problematic Rashi and actually use it to posek halacha. This is patently wrong and is מוציא לעז on Rashi. According to the 9th עיקר אמונה of the Rambam, mitzvot never change. This idea of Hashem doing our mitzvot goes against the principles of faith. More importantly, Rashi in at least 5 other places says explicitly man will build the Mikdash וְיִשְׁמְרוּ אֶת כָּל צוּרָתוֹ - רש'י --ילמדו עניני מידות מפיך שידעו לעשותם לעת קץ. יחזקאל מג יא. All Rishonim and Achronim say man must build the mikdash. I can send you the list. No achron takes this Rashi to heart. In fact, according to כללי הש'ס , Rashi is only a parshan and not a posek. see יד מלאכי and see בית יוסף אורח חיים סימן י ולענין הלכה נראה דאע"ג דהרא"ש מפרש כפירוש רש"י כיון דרש"י מפרש הוא ולא פסקן הוו להו הרמב"ם והרא"ש ז"ל חד לגבי חד והלכה כהרמב"ם ז"לד דמסתבר טעמיה דבנתכוין לאוסופי פסול ובנתכוין לבטולי כשר ועוד שדברי רב פפא מיפרשי שפיר טפי אליביה ממאי דמיפרשי אליביה דרש"י: Most importantly, the mikdash is not just one mitzvah but a trigger for over 200 mitzvot that can only be done on har habayit. How can one based on acryptic Rashi uproot 1/3 of the Torah when we have a klal of תורה לאו בשמים היא. WE MUST DO ALL MITZVOT. I live in Israel and go up to Har habyit. I have learned Kodshim for over 15 years and have investigated this topic thorougly. I actually graduated YU in 88. You are clearly a talmid chacham and you give a great shiur . I mean no disrespect, but feel these issues are often treated very שטחי and require a more in-depth understanding. The number one question that must be answered with regard to this Rashi is: can Hashem do our mitzvot for us and if so, when did Hashem change his Torah and mitzvot that he gave on Har sinai? תורה היא וללמוד אני צריך. ABBA HOROVITZ
    3. Title: BEIT HAMIKDASH
      Author: ABBA HOROVITZ
      Reply
      Shalom, I listened to your podcast on Binyan hamikdash and feel that you presented a very one sided understanding of Rashi . Great Rabbis in our generation have unfortunately used this Rashi to deflect all responsibility of binyan hamikdash and have thrown the entire enterprise onto God. Instead of questioning this Rashi and determining whether this is shitas Rashi in the rest of Shas and Torah, they flippantly embrace this problematic Rashi and actually use it to posek halacha. This is patently wrong and is מוציא לעז on Rashi. According to the 9th עיקר אמונה of the Rambam, mitzvot never change. This idea of Hashem doing our mitzvot goes against the principles of faith. More importantly, Rashi in at least 5 other places says explicitly man will build the Mikdash וְיִשְׁמְרוּ אֶת כָּל צוּרָתוֹ - רש'י --ילמדו עניני מידות מפיך שידעו לעשותם לעת קץ. יחזקאל מג יא. All Rishonim and Achronim say man must build the mikdash. I can send you the list. No achron takes this Rashi to heart. In fact, according to כללי הש'ס , Rashi is only a parshan and not a posek. see יד מלאכי and see בית יוסף אורח חיים סימן י ולענין הלכה נראה דאע"ג דהרא"ש מפרש כפירוש רש"י כיון דרש"י מפרש הוא ולא פסקן הוו להו הרמב"ם והרא"ש ז"ל חד לגבי חד והלכה כהרמב"ם ז"לד דמסתבר טעמיה דבנתכוין לאוסופי פסול ובנתכוין לבטולי כשר ועוד שדברי רב פפא מיפרשי שפיר טפי אליביה ממאי דמיפרשי אליביה דרש"י: Most importantly, the mikdash is not just one mitzvah but a trigger for over 200 mitzvot that can only be done on har habayit. How can one based on acryptic Rashi uproot 1/3 of the Torah when we have a klal of תורה לאו בשמים היא. WE MUST DO ALL MITZVOT. I live in Israel and go up to Har habyit. I have learned Kodshim for over 15 years and have investigated this topic thorougly. I actually graduated YU in 88. You are clearly a talmid chacham and you give a great shiur . I mean no disrespect, but feel these issues are often treated very שטחי and require a more in-depth understanding. The number one question that must be answered with regard to this Rashi is: can Hashem do our mitzvot for us and if so, when did Hashem change his Torah and mitzvot that he gave on Har sinai? תורה היא וללמוד אני צריך. ABBA HOROVITZ

    Learning on the Marcos and Adina Katz YUTorah site is sponsored today by Miriam & Alan Goldberg and Ruth Peyser Kestenbaum to mark the thirteenth yahrtzeit of their father, Irwin Peyser, Harav Yisroel Chaim ben R’ Dovid V’ Fraidah Raizel Peyser and for a refuah shleimah for Yisrael Moshe ben Chaya Rivka